Total Commander

2andry81
I seriously doubt Ghisler will change the function/behavior/action of these shortcuts after decades of handing the operation to the shell. It would break so many things, most importantly user expectations who've been using them for so long.

Hence I second elgonzo's suggestion that this can easily be solved by a small script. I'm sure users can help you if necessary.

Regards
Dalai

Dalai wrote: ↑2020-11-20, 20:13 UTC TC already supports long paths in the regular copy (F5) and move (F6) operations.
As Ghisler said, Ctrl+C/Ctrl+V/Ctrl+X is intentionally handled by Explorer (or the shell),
and that supports long paths only on Win10 (not sure which release) out of the box.

Regards
Dalai

With the Anniversary Update of Windows 10, you can finally abandon the 260 character maximum path limit in Windows.
The Anniversary Update will report itself as version 1607.
Version 1607 (OS build 14393) - Availability date: 2016-08-02

Dalai wrote: ↑2020-11-20, 22:41 UTC 2andry81
I seriously doubt Ghisler will change the function/behavior/action of these shortcuts after decades of handing the operation to the shell. It would break so many things, most importantly user expectations who've been using them for so long.

Why not just add an option to use internal TC copy on ctrl-c+ctrl-v?

Dalai wrote: ↑2020-11-20, 22:41 UTC Hence I second elgonzo's suggestion that this can easily be solved by a small script. I'm sure users can help you if necessary.

It's worser because a user have to click on a button bar or use custom key press instead of simple known ctrl-v press.

andry81 wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 01:19 UTC

Dalai wrote: ↑2020-11-20, 22:41 UTC Hence I second elgonzo's suggestion that this can easily be solved by a small script. I'm sure users can help you if necessary.

It's worser because a user have to click on a button bar or use custom key press instead of simple known ctrl-v press.

If you want to duplicate a file, how would pressing Ctrl+D (or any other chosen hotkey) n-times to create n duplicates be any worse than pressing Ctrl+C followed by pressing Ctrl+V n-times? And if you happen to dislike using any other hotkey than Ctrl+V, have you already tried remapping Ctrl+V in TC (just to see whether a Ctrl+V remapping is actually working in TC)?

andry81 wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 01:19 UTCWhy not just add an option to use internal TC copy on ctrl-c+ctrl-v?

The thing is: When these shortcuts are handled internally, the copy dialog appears - but that's not what you want either. We're running in circles here...

It's worser because a user have to click on a button bar or use custom key press instead of simple known ctrl-v press.

It's no problem to assign a shortcut to a user-defined command (see TC Options > Misc section), and I think that it also works with Ctrl+V (not sure because I haven't tried it). Such a user-defined command could execute a script as was already pointed out by elgonzo.

Regards
Dalai

elgonzo wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 07:32 UTC If you want to duplicate a file, how would pressing Ctrl+D (or any other chosen hotkey) n-times to create n duplicates be any worse than pressing Ctrl+C followed by pressing Ctrl+V n-times?

Because with the ctrl-v you still can select another panel to paste in.

Dalai wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 11:12 UTC The thing is: When these shortcuts are handled internally, the copy dialog appears - but that's not what you want either. We're running in circles here...

Not quite sure that you mean. For example, a copy dialog does appear for the F5/Shift-F5, but not for the ctrl-c+ctrl-v.

Dalai wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 11:12 UTC It's no problem to assign a shortcut to a user-defined command (see TC Options > Misc section), and I think that it also works with Ctrl+V (not sure because I haven't tried it). Such a user-defined command could execute a script as was already pointed out by elgonzo.

That would be an ugly approach to simulate TC functionality which already has to be a built in, without any dialogs and external scripts.

andry81 wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 17:02 UTC Because with the ctrl-v you still can select another panel to paste in.

That you can also do with a usercommand, regardless of the hotkey. Whether you want to duplicate into the the same panel/directory as the source file, or duplicate another directory in the other panel is just a matter of how you setup the usercommand...

elgonzo wrote: ↑2020-11-21, 17:09 UTC That you can also do with a usercommand, regardless of the hotkey.

There is always be a corner case or other bad thing which you won't be able to resolve only with a usercommand. For example, a MTP device can not be handled using a file path because MTP has it's own API and not visible from a usercommand. So you won't be able to run a command in a directory of an android phone SD-card or on a Phone Flash storage. It's not quite relevant, but shows how the implementation would be incomplete or broken.